Love the open nature of this bag. Easy access to all discs. Very lightweight and holds just about everything I would need.

Would love some more durabilty on the straps as they fray easily and padding is not great. A retriver pocket would be about the only addition I'd add as I'm currently just using the water bottle holder to drop my retriever in.

It also does not stand up great.

It has been my bag for 2 years now though so it's hanging in there. Would recommend for casual use

I had this bag for a little over a year. I LOVED it... mostly. Super accessable and easy to organize. I really like have the putters up so high and easy to get to. It didn't handle carrying a disc retriever well though and pretty quicly the cup holder i was trying to use to hold it tore out. Then over the last couple of weeks the seams that hold the main front compartment together started falling apart and it's done. Only really lasting 1 year is kinda a bummer. 
Things they could fix:
Retirever/umbrella/stool purpose built solution.
nubs or rails for the bottom - the moisture exasperated wear
a general more quality build

 

I have one of these bags for backup. I like the accessibility of it. Very easy to put discs in and out of but it doesn't have great balance. It can get top heavy and fall a lot. On hills it tends to fall over a lot too. I think this would be a great bad to put in a cart though or for quick rounds